I would not simply walk into Council and say, “Cut municipal taxes by 50%.” Responsible municipal government requires us to understand the numbers first. The first step would be to put the question through the proper municipal process and seek a comprehensive review of the City's finances, spending, contracts, reserves, staffing, programs, revenues, obligations and service levels.
The Honest Premise
The purpose is simple:
Find out exactly what government costs, what is required, what is discretionary, where efficiencies exist, and what can realistically be changed.
The 50% figure is the taxpayer-relief target I would ask the City to examine. It is a target for the review — not a claim that 50% can already be achieved without a detailed financial analysis. The actual reduction would have to be supported by identified savings, efficiencies, restructuring, revenues and other lawful measures, and implemented through the appropriate municipal decisions and votes.
Put the Question Before Council
The first step would be to bring forward a formal motion for a comprehensive Municipal Taxpayer Relief Review, debated publicly and put to a vote of Council.
The motion would direct the City's administration, through the appropriate municipal process, to conduct a comprehensive examination of the City's finances, spending, contracts, reserves, staffing, programs, revenues, obligations and service levels.
I intend to work with Council to pass this motion through a Council vote. I would not rely on special mayoral powers to impose this review. This should be a transparent decision made through the normal democratic process, with elected members of Council having the opportunity to debate the proposal, ask questions and vote.
Council has to be involved. The numbers have to be examined. And the public has to be able to see the results. This is not about one person deciding what gets cut. It is about asking the entire municipal government to show taxpayers what their money is paying for and what can realistically be changed.
Start With the Actual Numbers
The review would begin with the City's existing financial information. That means examining:
- Operating budgets
- Capital budgets
- Audited consolidated financial statements
- Financial Information Returns
- Reserves and reserve funds
- Debt
- Investments
- Municipal assets
- Revenues
- Staffing
- Contracts
- Procurement
- Consultants
- Professional services
- Legal expenses
- Technology
- Communications
- Grants
- Programs
- Administration
- Other recurring expenditures
The City currently publishes its financial statements and Financial Information Returns as part of its financial reporting. Its published financial-reporting page currently lists 2024 consolidated financial statements as the latest consolidated statements available there.
The objective would be to establish a clear picture of where every major portion of the municipal tax dollar is going.
Show the numbers.
Examine Different Tax-Reduction Scenarios
The review would not jump directly from today's tax structure to a 50% reduction. City administration should be asked to model multiple scenarios:
Additional scenarios could also be examined if financially and legally appropriate. For each scenario, taxpayers should be able to see:
- What would have to change
- What savings could potentially be achieved
- What efficiencies could be found
- What spending could potentially be reduced
- What contracts could potentially be renegotiated
- What procurement savings may exist
- What administrative savings may be possible
- What alternative revenues are available
- What reserves could or could not be changed
- What impact changes could have on debt
- What impact changes could have on services
- What legal or contractual restrictions exist
No guessing. No slogans. The numbers.
Examine Major Spending Categories
A major part of the review would be a detailed examination of significant operating expenditures.
Administration & Staffing
Review the organizational structure, management layers, staffing levels, duplication and opportunities to improve efficiency — while recognizing applicable legal and collective-agreement requirements.
Consultants & Professional Services
Determine what the City is paying outside organizations and whether particular services could be reduced, renegotiated, consolidated or performed internally where legally and operationally practical.
Contracts & Procurement
Review major contracts, their costs, renewal dates, terms and procurement methods to identify potential savings and opportunities for better value.
Programs & Grants
Determine which programs are mandatory, which are discretionary, what they cost and what measurable public benefit they provide.
Technology & Communications
Examine recurring technology, software, communications and related expenditures for duplication, unnecessary costs or opportunities for greater efficiency.
Legal & Other Professional Expenses
Review recurring expenditures and determine whether efficiencies or alternative approaches are available.
This is about understanding the cost of government before asking taxpayers to pay more for government.
Separate What Is Required From What Is Optional
Not every dollar in the municipal budget is treated the same way. Some services and expenditures are required by law. Some are necessary for public safety and core municipal operations. Others are discretionary or subject to policy choices. The review should clearly identify these categories.
And most importantly: what each of those decisions costs.
Review Contracts and Outside Spending
Major municipal contracts and recurring external expenditures should be examined individually. The review should identify:
- Contract value
- Renewal dates
- Termination provisions
- Procurement process
- Current service costs
- Opportunities to renegotiate
- Opportunities to consolidate
- Opportunities for competitive procurement
- Whether in-house delivery is legally and operationally practical
The question is: are taxpayers receiving the best value for what we are spending?
Review Reserves, All Investments and Municipal Assets
The City has reserves, reserve funds, investments and other financial resources. Those should also be examined. For each major reserve or fund, taxpayers should be able to understand:
- What it exists for
- How much is currently held
- What restrictions apply
- What minimum balance is required
- How much is contributed each year
- Whether contributions can legally and responsibly be changed
- What the long-term consequences would be
The same applies to municipal investments and other sources of non-tax revenue. The goal would be to determine whether any revenues or financial resources can lawfully and sustainably be used to reduce the municipal tax burden without creating a future financial problem.
Compare Niagara Falls With Other Municipalities
The City should compare its costs and service-delivery models with comparable municipalities, including:
- Administrative costs
- Staffing
- Service delivery
- Procurement
- Infrastructure
- Operating expenditures
- Other significant municipal costs
The purpose is not to assume another municipality has the answer. The purpose is to ask: why does this cost what it costs here?
If another municipality is delivering a reasonably comparable service at a significantly different cost, Council and taxpayers should understand why.
Protect All Essential Emergency Services
A tax-reduction review should not simply mean cutting essential services. Public safety, core municipal services, statutory responsibilities and necessary infrastructure must be considered.
The priority would be to look for savings through:
- Efficiency
- Accountability
- Restructuring
- Procurement
- Elimination of duplication
- Alternative revenues
… before simply cutting essential services.
Where a proposed reduction cannot legally or financially be made, the City should explain why. Not simply: “We can't do that.” But: “Here is the legal, contractual, financial or operational reason we cannot do that.” Taxpayers deserve an explanation supported by facts.
Bring the Findings Back to Council
Once the review is completed, the findings should come back through the appropriate public Council process. Council and the public should be able to see:
- Where municipal tax dollars are being spent
- What services actually cost
- What spending is mandatory
- What spending is discretionary
- Where savings were identified
- Which savings can actually be implemented
- What changes would affect services
- What level of municipal tax reduction each option could produce
This is where the actual decisions and votes would happen.
What Does a 50–100% Municipal Tax Reduction Actually Mean?
This distinction is extremely important.
The 50–100% target refers to the municipal / City portion of the property-tax burden — not 50–100% of the entire property-tax bill.
The City of Niagara Falls states that, for its 2026 residential property-tax example, approximately 37% of the total property tax is attributable to the City, 54% to the Region and 9% to education. The City is responsible for setting the tax rates for the City portion; Council does not control the taxes imposed by the other taxing authorities.
The City's published 2026 illustration uses a total property-tax bill of $4,900, of which $1,813 is the City's share. A 50% reduction in that illustrative municipal share would be approximately $906.50, assuming the other portions of the bill remained unchanged.
That is an illustration, not a promise of a specific homeowner's future tax bill. Actual taxes vary by property assessment, tax class and the tax rates established by the applicable taxing authorities.
What Happens If 50–100% Isn't Achievable?
This is an important part of the plan. I am not asking taxpayers to accept a number without evidence. If the review determines that a 50–100% municipal tax reduction cannot legally, financially or operationally be achieved, then the City should show taxpayers the mathematics behind that conclusion.
- What is the current municipal tax requirement?
- What costs cannot be changed?
- What contracts restrict reductions?
- What statutory obligations exist?
- What savings were identified?
- What savings were rejected?
- What alternatives were examined?
- What is the remaining financial gap?
- What further reductions could still be achieved?
This Is How the Process Would Work
Introduce the Proposal
Bring forward a formal proposal for a comprehensive Municipal Taxpayer Relief Review through the appropriate municipal process.
Council Considers the Proposal
Council considers the proposal and takes the appropriate action under the Municipal Act and applicable City procedures.
Staff Conduct the Review
The CAO, Treasurer and appropriate City departments examine the City's finances, spending and operations within their legal authorities.
The Numbers Come Back
Council receives financial analysis and multiple municipal tax-reduction scenarios, including 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 75% and 100%.
The Public Sees the Information
The findings are presented through the appropriate public process and made available to residents.
Council Debates the Options
Council examines what can legally, financially and responsibly be changed.
Council Makes the Appropriate Decisions
Specific spending changes, restructuring, efficiencies, revenue measures and tax-rate changes would be implemented only through the appropriate legal and municipal decision-making processes.
Taxpayer Relief Is Measured
The City should report what was actually saved and what municipal tax reduction those savings produced.
The Principle Is Simple
I am not asking you to take my word for it. I am asking the City to open the books, examine the numbers and show taxpayers what is possible.
The 50% figure is the target for the review. The actual reductions would have to come from identified savings, efficiencies, restructuring, revenues and other lawful measures, and ultimately be implemented through the proper municipal process.
Because before we ask taxpayers to pay more, we should first prove that we are getting the most out of what they already pay.
before increasing the cost to taxpayers. SHOW US THE BOOKS.